I Photographed My Eyes Every Day For A Month While Testing These 5 Eye Creams

HOME >> WOMEN >> FACE

Monday, July 7, 2025 in FACE

I PHOTOGRAPHED MY EYES EVERY DAY FOR A MONTH WHILE TESTING THESE 5 EYE CREAMS.

And no. It’s not Botox or under eye fillers. Just some surprisingly good natural eye creams.

I Basically Became My Own Guinea Pig Testing These 5 Natural Eye Creams. The Winner Wasn't What I Expected.

I’ve never been totally against Botox or fillers. 

They work for a lot of people. But for me? They just feel like too much.

Too clinical, too expensive, and honestly—just not the vibe I want for my face.

A friend told me you have to go back every six months to maintain it, and that kind of sealed the deal for me.

I’m 35 now, and honestly… I just want something I can do at home.

Something simple, natural, and low-maintenance.

So I gave a few eye creams a try. Nothing crazy, just ones that felt a bit gentler, a bit more thoughtful.

Some were nice. Most were forgettable. But one? One actually made me do a double take.

Around the third week, I looked at a photo and thought,

 ”Wait…do my eyes look brighter?”

If you’re not ready for needles, but still want to feel like your face finally caught up with how you feel inside…

these might be worth a try!

1. Fountain’s Bakuchiol Eye Repair Cream

Effectiveness: 94% 
Safety: 100% 
Price: $$ 
Overall Rating: A++

There’s something about tired eyes that hits different.

Like, you can feel totally fine and still look like you haven’t slept in days.

That was me. The dullness, puffiness, and subtle creasing under my eyes started to linger, no matter what I did.

I didn’t want to jump straight to fillers, but I also wasn’t interested in wasting money on another overpriced cream.

Fountain’s Eye Repair Cream caught my attention because it’s made with Bakuchiol—a gentle, plant-based alternative to retinol. No irritation. No peeling. Just slow, steady results.

The texture is soft, almost weightless. It layers well under makeup and feels like a quiet little reset for your skin.

After about two weeks, I started noticing changes.

The puffiness looked calmer. My eyes seemed more awake. And that dull, worn-out look? Starting to fade.

It’s also infused with Chamomile, Hyaluronic Acid, and Caffeine, so you get hydration, soothing, and a subtle tightening effect—without ever feeling tight or dry.

It didn’t promise miracles. It didn’t need to.  It just worked and that alone makes it rare.

If you want something natural, effective, and genuinely kind to your skin, this is the one to try.

2. RoC Retinol Correxion Line Smoothing Eye Cream

Effectiveness: 78% 
Safety: 65% 
Price: $$ 
Overall Rating: B-

I picked this up because Kim Kardashian swears by it, and honestly, I get the appeal.

It’s lightweight, fragrance-free, and backed by years of retinol research.

But even after gradually easing it into my routine, I started to notice flaking and irritation.

The fine lines around my eyes looked slightly softer, but not enough to justify how dry my skin felt most days.

Especially when the product’s marketing promised dramatic results that never really showed up.

A few other reviewers had the same experience, especially those with sensitive skin like mine.

If your skin does well with retinol, this could work for you. But if not, there are gentler options out there that are just as effective without the trade-offs.

3. Origins Ginzing Refreshing Eye Cream

Effectiveness: 70% 
Safety: 85% 
Price: $$ 
Overall Rating: B

This one’s all over TikTok.

Yes, I use TikTok.

It’s cute, it’s colorful, and it promises to brighten and de-puff with Vitamin C, Niacinamide, and Ginseng.

At first, I really liked it.

The texture is lightweight, it sinks in fast, and the peachy tint gives a quick boost that looks great under makeup.

But after a few weeks, I started to notice something.

The glow it gave was mostly temporary. It brightened a little on the surface, but my dark circles and tired eyes still looked the same once it wore off.

It’s not a bad product. It just felt more like a cosmetic boost than real skincare. 

Nice for daytime, especially if you want to look more awake, but it didn’t do much beyond that.

If you’re after quick glow and light hydration, this might do the trick.

But for deeper results, you might want something with more lasting power.

4. Herbivore Botanicals Moon Dew Retinol Alternative Eye Cream

Effectiveness: 72% 
Safety: 90% 
Price: $$$ 
Overall Rating: B

This one had me excited right away. The packaging is beautiful, the formula looked promising with Bakuchiol, peptides, and tremella mushroom, and it’s from a brand that’s big in the clean beauty world.

The texture is silky and light. It glides on easily, feels cooling on the skin, and layers well under makeup.

But after a few weeks, I just wasn’t seeing much change.

My under-eyes felt hydrated, but the dark circles and puffiness still looked the same. It was more of a nice step in the routine rather than a product that made a visible difference.

If dryness is your main concern or you’re into clean formulas with a soothing feel, this could be a nice fit.

But if you’re expecting firming, brightening, or real transformation, this might fall a little short.

5. Acure Radically Rejuvenating Eye Cream

Effectiveness: 68% 
Safety: 90% 
Price: $ 
Overall Rating: B-

This one’s definitely a go-to in the affordable clean beauty space.

The name alone makes you want to believe it’ll do the most and with Bakuchiol, caffeine, aloe, and turmeric, it really sounds like it should.

And to be fair, it does feel nice.

Lightweight, no greasiness, and easy to wear day or night.

But once I got past the nice texture, I started realizing I wasn’t seeing much else.
 
No real brightening, no change in puffiness, and the fine lines were…still there.

Also, the scent caught me off guard. It’s not strong, but it’s definitely there. If you’re sensitive to fragrance, it might not be your favorite thing to have sitting under your eyes.

It’s not a bad product, especially at this price point.

But if you’re hoping for noticeable results, it might leave you underwhelmed.

WHY FOUNTAIN’S BAKUCHIOL EYE REPAIR CREAM EARNED MY #1 RECOMMENDATION

I didn’t expect much from this, to be honest.

The formula sounded nice. Bakuchiol instead of Retinol, which I prefer but I’ve been let down before.

Still, it felt good. No stinging, no weird smell. Just light, hydrating, and calming.

And after a couple of weeks, my under-eyes looked less puffy. That dry, dull look? Softer.

It wasn’t some huge transformation.

But I noticed enough to keep using it. And weirdly… I actually finished the whole tube.

That’s a first.

I didn’t even realize how often I was using it until I noticed the tube was nearly empty.

It wasn’t a big “wow” moment.

No dramatic glow-up. Just… subtle changes that stuck.

My eyes looked a little more rested. 

My skin around my eye area became more youthful!  

And I wasn’t reaching for concealer as much.

It became easy to use—because it didn’t irritate my skin or make promises it couldn’t keep.

It just did what it was supposed to do.

And honestly, that’s rare.

SO, WHY DOES IT ACTUALLY WORK?

I’ll be honest—at first, I had no clue what made this different.

But I see some changes and it really got me curious so I started reading up.

I learned that over time, skin starts to lose firmness.
 Not just from aging, but from things like dehydration, poor circulation, and a drop in collagen.

That’s when the texture changes.
 Skin starts to look looser. Less defined. Almost like it’s deflating.

This cream is made to target all of that. 

It helps restore hydration, support elasticity, and smooth out the surface—so your skin actually feels firmer and more toned.

Not overnight. 
But day by day… you start to notice the difference.

THE POWER TRIO: 3 INGREDIENTS THAT TRANSFORMED MY EYE AREA

So what makes this eye cream actually different?

It’s not packed with harsh ingredients or artificial fillers.

Instead, it’s built around three gentle yet effective actives that help bring your under-eyes back to life.

Bakuchiol 
A plant-based alternative to Retinol that helps smooth fine lines and support skin renewal—without the irritation.

Niacinamide 
Known to brighten the under-eye area, even out tone, and reduce the look of dark circles over time.

Caffeine 
Helps depuff and tighten, giving your eyes a more awake, refreshed appearance.

SO HERE'S THE REAL DEAL...

Honestly speaking, the changes were not overnight or within a week.

I did not wake up with brand new eyes (I wish I could though)

I didn’t look as puffy in the morning.

The fine lines weren’t as harsh under certain lighting.

And for once, I didn’t feel the need to overdo it with concealer.

It didn’t promise the world—and maybe that’s why I actually trusted it.

FOUNTAIN BAKUCHIOL EYE CREAM TESTIMONIALS

“I didn’t notice anything at first, but I kept using it. And one day, I realized I hadn’t reached for concealer all week.” 
— Lisa, 35

“I’ve always been sensitive to eye creams, so I almost gave up. This one didn’t sting. Didn’t irritate. I just kept using it and eventually, I noticed a difference.” 
— Mara, 42

“I usually tap on some concealer right after moisturizer. Lately? I haven’t felt like I needed to. That’s kinda big for me.” 
— Sarah, 28

264,235 Comments

Add a comment...

Rachel Kim

I didn’t expect much tbh but wow... this eye cream feels SO good on the skin. 👀💧

Like · Reply ·